|
Appeal for the Channel Islands with jurisdiction to
hear appeals from both Islands. The Suggestions and Recommendations
set out the then existing jurisdiction of the Royal Court of Guernsey
whether sitting as a Full Court or an Ordinary Court, and form a
useful summary of the relevant jurisdiction of the courts in the
Island at that time.
In criminal cases no appeal lay as to conviction or
sentence save by special leave to Her Majesty in Council.
As to the civil jurisdiction, the Full Court sitting
as the Cour des Jugements et Records was described as
"the Court of Appeal from all decisions of the Ordinary Court
where the amount in dispute exceeds the sum of £25 and on points
of law from those where the amount in dispute is less than the
foregoing or where no amount is involved…. A further appeal lies
to the Judicial Committee of His Majesty's Privy Council ...",
Thus there was a right of appeal within the Island as to civil
matters but not from criminal convictions or sentences on indictment.
The Full Court comprised the Bailiff or Lieutenant Bailiff and
not less than seven Jurats, while the ordinary Court, which had
the original jurisdiction in all civil matters and what was described
by this Court in Century at page 3 as a "dwindling jurisdiction"
in criminal matters, comprised one of these Judges and two Jurats.
It follows that there was no appeal procedure in the case of serious
criminal convictions and sentences, the only remedy being the expensive
bringing of an application for special leave and its prosecution
before the Judicial Committee.
|